Sheepshead Baygels | Bagel Shop in Holmdel, NJ

Sheepshead
Baygels

Jersey-born bagels with that signature crunch. Handcrafted fresh daily in Holmdel, NJ.

Order Online
4.6 · 3,404 reviews
Fresh bagels and breakfast sandwiches at Sheepshead Baygels in Holmdel NJ
Jersey's Finest

The Sheepshead Way

At Sheepshead Baygels, every bagel starts with a time-honored tradition: boiled then baked to create that unforgettable crunch on the outside and pillowy softness within. We're not just making breakfast - we're carrying on a proud New York-style bagel legacy right here on Route 35 in Holmdel, New Jersey. From our classic cream cheese spreads to our legendary Hangover Cure Breakfast Sandwich stacked high with pork roll, bacon, egg, cheese, and golden hash browns, every bite tells a story of quality ingredients and genuine care. Whether you're a morning regular grabbing your go-to egg and cheese or a weekend warrior exploring our full menu of deli favorites, we treat every order like it's for family. Our kitchen runs on passion, our bagels are rolled by hand, and our community keeps coming back because they know the difference between good and great. That's the Sheepshead way - honest food, done right, every single day.

Fresh Daily
Handcrafted
Delivery

What's Rollin'

Our most-loved bagels and sandwiches, fresh out of the kitchen

Egg, Choice of Meat and Cheese breakfast sandwich on a fresh bagel

Egg, Choice of Meat & Cheese

Your choice of egg preparation paired with sausage, bacon, pork roll, ham, or a meatless option, topped with melted cheese on a fresh bagel.

Freshly baked bagel with smooth cream cheese spread

Cream Cheese

A freshly baked bagel generously spread with smooth, creamy cream cheese.

Classic egg and cheese sandwich on grilled bread

Egg & Cheese

Classic egg and cheese sandwich with your choice of fried, over easy, scrambled, or sunny side up egg, served with melted cheese on grilled bread.

Savory pork roll with melted cheese on a poppy seed bun

Pork Roll & Cheese

Savory pork roll with melted cheese served on a poppy seed bun - a classic deli favorite.

Warm freshly baked bagel with butter spread

Butter

A warm, freshly boiled and baked bagel served with a generous spread of butter.

Hangover Cure Breakfast Sandwich with pork roll bacon egg cheese and hash browns

Hangover Cure Breakfast Sandwich

The ultimate morning fix - pork roll, crispy bacon, egg, melted cheese, and golden hash browns all stacked on one hearty sandwich.

Word on the Street

4.6
3,404 ratings
"
I get food 2-3 times a week and the sandwiches are always really good. Bagels always have that signature sheepshead crunch but soft inside, top quality tasty food reasonably priced
Bryan G
"
Great place for breakfast. Their banana nut muffin is the best I've had. And their bagels are outstanding. I love their breakfast sandwiches always top-notch.
Louis S

Good Questions

What meals do you serve?
Sheepshead Baygels serves classic American bagel sandwiches perfect for breakfast and lunch in Holmdel, NJ. Our menu features crowd favorites like the Egg, Choice of Meat & Cheese, where guests pick their egg style and protein, including bacon, sausage, pork roll, or ham. We also offer a savory Pork Roll & Cheese on a poppy seed bun and a simple, satisfying Egg & Cheese on grilled bread. Cream cheese bagels and buttered bagels round out our traditional offerings. Whether you're grabbing a quick morning bite or a casual lunch, Sheepshead Baygels has something delicious for everyone.

Do you offer delivery or takeout?
Yes, we offer both delivery and pickup. Order conveniently online or by phone.

Where are you located?
We are located at 2095 NJ-35, Holmdel, NJ 07733, easily accessible along Route 35.

What areas do you serve?
Sheepshead Baygels proudly serves Holmdel and surrounding areas including Hazlet, Keyport, Keansburg, Aberdeen, Matawan, Middletown, Red Bank, Colts Neck, Marlboro, and Morganville, NJ.

Come Find Us

Address 2095 NJ-35, Holmdel, NJ 07733
Phone (732) 706-1266
Order Online Now

© 2026 Sheepshead Baygels. All rights reserved.

Checking if the site connection is secured...