FEATURED
Egg, Choice of Meat & CheeseChoice of egg preparation; paired with sausage, bacon, pork roll, ham, or meatless option.
Cream CheeseA bagel generously spread with smooth cream cheese.
Egg & CheeseEgg sandwich with choice of fried, over easy, scrambled, or sunny side up egg. Served with cheese on grilled bread.
Pork Roll & CheeseSavory pork roll with melted cheese on a poppy seed bun.
ABOUT US
Welcome to Sheepshead Baygels in Holmdel—your neighborhood spot for fresh-baked bagels, hearty breakfast sandwiches, deli classics, and irresistible bakery treats. Start your day with a signature Belly Busta or Hangover Cure sandwich, or grab a hand-rolled bagel with your favorite cream cheese. From crisp salads to oven-fresh muffins and cookies, there’s something for everyone. Stop by and taste why we’re Holmdel’s go-to for breakfast, lunch, and everything in between!
REVIEWS
See what our customers are saying.
I get food 2-3 times a week and the sandwiches are always really good. Bagels always have that signature sheepshead crunch but soft inside, top quality tasty food reasonably priced
Bryan G
Great place for breakfast. Their banana nut muffin is the best I've had. And their bagels are outstanding. I love their breakfast sandwiches always top-notch. 
Louis S
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What meals do you serve?
Sheepshead Baygels in Holmdel offers a delicious variety of meals throughout the day, including breakfast, lunch, and bakery treats. Start your morning with our signature bagels, breakfast sandwiches like the Hangover Cure or Belly Busta, and fresh omelettes. For lunch, enjoy deli classics such as cold cut sandwiches, salads, and wraps, featuring premium meats and cheeses. Our bakery selection includes muffins, cookies, and crumb cake, perfect for a sweet treat any time. Whether you crave a hearty sandwich, fresh salad, or classic bagel, Sheepshead Baygels has something for everyone.
Do you offer delivery or takeout?
Yes, we offer both delivery and takeout options through trusted platforms like DoorDash for your convenience.
Where are you located?
We are located in Holmdel, New Jersey, serving the local community with fresh bagels and deli favorites.
What areas do you serve?
Sheepshead Baygels proudly serves Holmdel and surrounding neighborhoods including Hazlet, Middletown, Aberdeen, Matawan, Colts Neck, Marlboro, Keyport, Union Beach, Red Bank, and Lincroft, ensuring fresh bagels and deli delights reach our local community.
Where are your stores located?
- Address:2095 NJ-35, Holmdel, NJ 07733, USAPhone number:+17327061266Hours:
- Sunday07:30 AM - 11:55 AM
- Monday06:30 AM - 12:55 PM
- Tuesday06:30 AM - 12:55 PM
- Wednesday06:30 AM - 12:55 PM
- Thursday06:30 AM - 12:55 PM
- Friday06:30 AM - 12:55 PM
- Saturday07:30 AM - 12:40 PM
Copyright © 2026 Sheepshead Baygels. All Rights Reserved